Skip to content
Law Society of Scotland
Search
Find a Solicitor
Contact us
About us
Sign in
Search
Find a Solicitor
Contact us
About us
Sign in
  • For members

    • For members

    • CPD & Training

    • Membership and fees

    • Rules and guidance

    • Regulation and compliance

    • Journal

    • Business support

    • Career growth

    • Member benefits

    • Professional support

    • Lawscot Wellbeing

    • Lawscot Sustainability

  • News and events

    • News and events

    • Law Society news

    • Blogs & opinions

    • CPD & Training

    • Events

  • Qualifying and education

    • Qualifying and education

    • Qualifying as a Scottish solicitor

    • Career support and advice

    • Our work with schools

    • Lawscot Foundation

    • Funding your education

    • Social mobility

  • Research and policy

    • Research and policy

    • Research

    • Influencing the law and policy

    • Equality and diversity

    • Our international work

    • Legal Services Review

    • Meet the Policy team

  • For the public

    • For the public

    • What solicitors can do for you

    • Making a complaint

    • Client protection

    • Find a Solicitor

    • Frequently asked questions

    • Your Scottish solicitor

  • About us

    • About us

    • Contact us

    • Who we are

    • Our strategy, reports and plans

    • Help and advice

    • Our standards

    • Work with us

    • Our logo and branding

    • Equality and diversity

  1. Home
  2. News and events
  3. Blogs & opinions
  4. Can we legislate to keep people out of jail?

Can we legislate to keep people out of jail?

19th December 2008 | criminal law

Reaction to this week's Scottish Government announcement on sentencing reforms was pretty predictable, from "soft touch Scotland" frothing at the mouth in the tabloids (and from some politicians), to the more thoughtful pieces in other papers which recognise that there is a serious debate to be had.

Mr MacAskill has made much of the fact that short prison sentences amount to free bed and board at the taxpayer's expense, but offer little chance of rehabilitation and show a high rate of reoffending for those who have been through them. It is also more or less explicit in his remarks that there are a lot of people sentenced to prison who should not be there.

How is that so? We already have legislation that says an offender who has not been sent to prison before, should not receive a jail term "unless the court considers that no other method of dealing with him is appropriate". Unless this is not being used properly, those who have been through the system have already crossed this threshold. It is not so surprising therefore that judges are concerned that any further restrictions on their powers will amount to an undue interference with their decision making.

I do not doubt that more could be done by way of alternative programmes to try and change offending behaviour. The additional options proposed by the Government for deferred sentences etc must also be welcomed - judges should be encouraged to try any combination of measures they think might work in an individual case. But it will - or certainly should - take more than just another layer of legislation to make a significant difference to the prison population, and unless proper resources are made available to support genuine alternatives, the current proposals will prove no more workable than the attempts to date to reform early release.

The McLeish Commission recognised the need to back up its recommendations with resources. Does the Government?

Add To Favorites
Law Society of Scotland
Atria One, 144 Morrison Street
Edinburgh
EH3 8EX
If you’re looking for a solicitor, visit FindaSolicitor.scot
T: +44(0) 131 226 7411
E: lawscot@lawscot.org.uk
About us
  • Contact us
  • Who we are
  • Strategy reports plans
  • Help and advice
  • Our standards
  • Work with us
Useful links
  • Find a Solicitor
  • Sign in
  • CPD & Training
  • Rules and guidance
  • Website terms and conditions
Law Society of Scotland | © 2025
Made by Gecko Agency Limited