Skip to content
Law Society of Scotland
Search
Find a Solicitor
Contact us
About us
Sign in
Search
Find a Solicitor
Contact us
About us
Sign in
  • For members

    • For members

    • CPD & Training

    • Membership and fees

    • Rules and guidance

    • Regulation and compliance

    • Journal

    • Business support

    • Career growth

    • Member benefits

    • Professional support

    • Lawscot Wellbeing

    • Lawscot Sustainability

  • News and events

    • News and events

    • Law Society news

    • Blogs & opinions

    • CPD & Training

    • Events

  • Qualifying and education

    • Qualifying and education

    • Qualifying as a Scottish solicitor

    • Career support and advice

    • Our work with schools

    • Lawscot Foundation

    • Funding your education

    • Social mobility

  • Research and policy

    • Research and policy

    • Research

    • Influencing the law and policy

    • Equality and diversity

    • Our international work

    • Legal Services Review

    • Meet the Policy team

  • For the public

    • For the public

    • What solicitors can do for you

    • Making a complaint

    • Client protection

    • Find a Solicitor

    • Frequently asked questions

    • Your Scottish solicitor

  • About us

    • About us

    • Contact us

    • Who we are

    • Our strategy, reports and plans

    • Help and advice

    • Our standards

    • Work with us

    • Our logo and branding

    • Equality and diversity

  1. Home
  2. News and events
  3. Legal news
  4. ‘Compatibility issues’ review is published

‘Compatibility issues’ review is published

26th October 2018 | reviews

Appeals to the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (UKSC) should not require certification by the High Court of Justiciary that the issue raises a point of law of general public importance, a review chaired by the Lord Justice General has concluded.

The Review Group has published its report following a consultation on the practice and procedure relating to “compatibility issues” arising in criminal proceedings in Scotland.

The Scotland Act 2012 (sections 34 to 37) made several significant changes to criminal procedure in Scotland, including the introduction of compatibility issues and changes to the right of appeal to the UK Supreme Court.

A compatibility issue is a question, in criminal proceedings, of whether a public authority has acted unlawfully under the Human Rights Act, or in a way that is incompatible with EU law; or whether an Act of the Scottish Parliament is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights or EU law.

A review of these amendments was required by section 38 of the 2012 Act, and the Secretary of State for Scotland invited the Lord Justice General, Lord Carloway, to chair this review.

The Review Group gathered views on the practice and procedure relating to compatibility issues in criminal proceedings in Scotland and has now issued its recommendations and conclusions.

Summary of conclusions:

• The amendments made by the 2012 Act have reduced the burden that was placed on the Scottish criminal courts by the previous law and practice.
• An appeal to the UKSC on a compatibility issue should not require certification by the High Court that the issue raises a point of law of general public importance.
• There is merit in a single procedure through which an individual may challenge legislation on Convention or EU grounds. Such challenges should continue to be defined as a ‘compatibility issue’ and be subject to compatibility issue procedure.
• The Criminal Courts Rules Council should consider the extent to which amendment of Chapter 40 of the Criminal Procedure Rules is required in order to set out clearly the matters that must be specified in compatibility and devolution minutes.
• Applications for permission to appeal against a decision to refuse leave to appeal to either the Sheriff Appeal Court or the High Court should remain possible.
• The existing appeal time limits are appropriate and should not be amended.
• Law officers should not be required to seek permission to appeal to the UKSC against the determination of a compatibility issue referred to the High Court under section 288ZB(2) of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995.


Click here to access the review
 

Add To Favorites
Law Society of Scotland
Atria One, 144 Morrison Street
Edinburgh
EH3 8EX
If you’re looking for a solicitor, visit FindaSolicitor.scot
T: +44(0) 131 226 7411
E: lawscot@lawscot.org.uk
About us
  • Contact us
  • Who we are
  • Strategy reports plans
  • Help and advice
  • Our standards
  • Work with us
Useful links
  • Find a Solicitor
  • Sign in
  • CPD & Training
  • Rules and guidance
  • Website terms and conditions
Law Society of Scotland | © 2025
Made by Gecko Agency Limited