Skip to content
Law Society of Scotland
Search
Find a Solicitor
Contact us
About us
Sign in
Search
Find a Solicitor
Contact us
About us
Sign in
  • For members

    • For members

    • CPD & Training

    • Membership and fees

    • Rules and guidance

    • Regulation and compliance

    • Journal

    • Business support

    • Career growth

    • Member benefits

    • Professional support

    • Lawscot Wellbeing

    • Lawscot Sustainability

  • News and events

    • News and events

    • Law Society news

    • Blogs & opinions

    • CPD & Training

    • Events

  • Qualifying and education

    • Qualifying and education

    • Qualifying as a Scottish solicitor

    • Career support and advice

    • Our work with schools

    • Lawscot Foundation

    • Funding your education

    • Social mobility

  • Research and policy

    • Research and policy

    • Research

    • Influencing the law and policy

    • Equality and diversity

    • Our international work

    • Legal Services Review

    • Meet the Policy team

  • For the public

    • For the public

    • What solicitors can do for you

    • Making a complaint

    • Client protection

    • Find a Solicitor

    • Frequently asked questions

    • Your Scottish solicitor

  • About us

    • About us

    • Contact us

    • Who we are

    • Our strategy, reports and plans

    • Help and advice

    • Our standards

    • Work with us

    • Our logo and branding

    • Equality and diversity

  1. Home
  2. News and events
  3. Legal news
  4. EHRC calls for review of sexual history provisions

EHRC calls for review of sexual history provisions

19th August 2020 | criminal law | Criminal court work

An urgent review is needed of how courts and the Crown Office & Procurator Fiscal Service respond when survivors of sexual violence have details of their sex lives raised during sexual offences trials, according to the Equality & Human Rights Commission in Scotland.

The EHRC made its call as it published a report reviewing the literature and legal cases on the use of sexual history evidence and personal information in rape and sexual assault trials in Scotland. The report, commissioned by the EHRC from Professor Sharon Cowan at the University of Edinburgh Law School, also looks at how use of this evidence affects survivors’ access to justice.

The report finds evidence of a potential "justice gap" in Scotland, and identifies concerns about how effective the rape shield provisions are in practice. Intended to restrict evidence of sexual history and bad character to where there is a sufficient connection with the facts of the case, the law has been found to be compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights in balancing the rights of the accused and the complainer. But the report concludes that "in practice there appears to be ample room for improvement, particularly with respect to protecting the dignity and privacy of the complainer".

Conviction rates for rape and attempted rape remain 40% lower than for other crimes.

A lack of systematic data collection and research makes it difficult to scrutinise the operation of the provisions, but the little evidence which is available "suggests prosecutors rarely challenge the introduction of sexual history and bad character evidence. There is an urgent need to review how and when this evidence is introduced, and in particular, the extent to which it is challenged by prosecutors".

A need is also identified to strengthen the protections for people who bring forward allegations of sexual crimes, through legal and procedural reform. These include developing a model of state funded independent legal representation for complainers in hearings about the relevance of sexual history and bad character evidence, and clear rules on the retention of digital data to ensure complainers’ rights to privacy.

Laura Hutchison, head of compliance at the EHRC in Scotland, commented: "In five recent High Court appeal cases senior judges raised significant concerns about the way the law is being implemented in practice. As there is so little publicly available evidence, we are unable to say with confidence that the poor practices identified in these appeal court decisions are rare or do not have a significant and damaging effect on the dignity and privacy of survivors and their access to justice."

Click here to access the report and accompanying papers.

 

 

Add To Favorites

Additional

  • News and events

In this section

  • Law Society news
  • CPD & Training
  • Blogs & opinions
  • Events
  • 75th Anniversary

Categories

  • civil litigation
  • criminal law
  • employment
  • obituary
  • careers
  • practice management
  • law society of scotland
  • government-administration
  • welfare/benefits
  • family-child law
  • reparation
  • professional regulation
  • property (non-commercial)
  • insolvency
  • consumer
  • human rights
  • mental health-adult incapacity
  • planning/environment
  • europe
  • information technology
  • immigration
  • education-training
  • executries
  • corporate
  • commercial property
  • agriculture-crofting
  • dispute resolution
  • risk management
  • intellectual property
  • client relations
  • tax
  • licensing
  • banking-financial services
  • trusts-asset management
  • reviews
  • opinion
  • For the public
  • Research and policy
  • Regulation
  • Journal online news
  • interview

News Archive

  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013

Related articles

  • Jury trials to return to the islands in spring
  • SCTS revises criminal case backlog predictions
  • Current justice funding model unsustainable: MSP report
  • Crime figures up 3% in first full post-Covid year
Law Society of Scotland
Atria One, 144 Morrison Street
Edinburgh
EH3 8EX
If you’re looking for a solicitor, visit FindaSolicitor.scot
T: +44(0) 131 226 7411
E: lawscot@lawscot.org.uk
About us
  • Contact us
  • Who we are
  • Strategy reports plans
  • Help and advice
  • Our standards
  • Work with us
Useful links
  • Find a Solicitor
  • Sign in
  • CPD & Training
  • Rules and guidance
  • Website terms and conditions
Law Society of Scotland | © 2025
Made by Gecko Agency Limited